← Back to Best Deals

Published October 9, 2026 in Deal of the Week

Stewartstown has farmhouses for sale. Buyers keep saving this one.

By Jeremy Tolley
Real estate, Stewartstown, PA

This week's pick in Stewartstown is a 4,500 square foot Victorian farmhouse on acreage with a bank barn. It drew 147 saves on Zillow, well past what most listings see. That's 3.6 times the average save count among this week's finalists. Buyers watching Stewartstown are already getting alerted the moment homes like this one hit the market. A farmhouse like this doesn't show up on the market every week.

The numbers
Views on Zillow
Saves on Zillow
Homes analyzed
Fig 0.1 · The home. The full photo set unlocks once you text in for the details.
The home
4 bd · 3 ba · 4,500 sq ft
$ ▬▬▬,▬▬▬
Listed this week. Address: ▬▬ ▬▬▬▬▬ ▬▬
Priceheld backAddressheld back

Text me for the address — (717) 814-7519Opens your messages. No forms. We don't do forms.

In short
  1. Ranked first of 184 active homes scored in Stewartstown, PA this week.
  2. 4 beds, 3 baths, about 4,500 sq ft. Listed this week.
  3. Listings here have been up about 113 days.
  4. Price and address are held back. Ask and they come to you.

Buyers are circling this farmhouse, and the barn might be why.

While listed, it earned 147 saves and 1,375 views on Zillow. It ranked first on Zillow saves for the number of days it has been listed.

From the listing: “Welcome to the most iconic victorian farmhouse you're going to see in our lifetime!”

Saves on Zillow · Stewartstown, PA
  1. 1This home147 saves
  2. 2Finalist average41 saves
Zillow saves. Finalist average = the mean of this week's finalists in the area, this home included.
What stands out
  1. This 1800's oversized farmhouse features an addition with an oversized greatroom with builtin bookcases, 15+ft ceilings, a stone feature wall with a built-in woodstove, access to a…
  2. step onto original wood flooring, find more built-in cabinetry, a butler's stairwell, and of course a turret that spans to the third level.
  3. Updates within 5 years include: Master ensuite bathroom, roof, 90% of windows replaced, concrete porch, porch soffit, light fixtures, etc.

A farmhouse built for both history and acreage.

Here's what the numbers around Stewartstown show.

Avg. days listed
Active listings in this area have averaged 113.2 days on the market so far.
Active homes
Everything for sale here right now — the full set this pick was scored against.

Want the address, the price, and the full photo set?

Text the keyword below and I'll send you everything on this week's pick.

Text (717) 814-7519Text me

No spam, just this week's pick and the details you asked for.

HERE'S WHAT YOU'LL GET BACK
  1. The address, and the listing it belongs to.
  2. The photos, unblurred, all of them.
  3. 3. The price and the property tax details.
  4. 4. A straight answer from me if you've got questions.

Know someone who's been dreaming about a barn of their own? Send this one their way.

Jeremy Tolley
Keller Williams Keystone · (717) 814-7519 · JeremyTolley@kw.com
Privacy policyTerms of useDo not sell or share my informationAccessibility statementFair housing notice
Jeremy Tolley is a licensed real estate agent with Keller Williams Keystone (license #RB066690), license #RS346267. Market numbers come from MLS records and are believed accurate but not guaranteed. Nothing on this site is an appraisal or a promise of value. If your home is already listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation.
© 2026 Jeremy Tolley · Keller Williams KeystoneEQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITY